Book Reviews Blog

This page only shows books that have a review. By default in date order of reading with newest at top

Wednesday 12th July 2023

1997

The Lover of the Grave

Lydmouth #3

Author : Andrew Taylor

Summary :
Another murder in Lydmouth

Reviewed by Roger CO, on 12 Jul 2023

Review Summary :
Still in the 1950s small town bubble

More of the Same

Lydmouth is still trapped in the aspic of the 1950s with its dramas exaggerated. Much the same plot as the previous one in the series (and the same main characters of course - with the Dean replaced by the Actor).

A competent mystery with two or three distractions away from the main whodunit providing other possible suspects. Actually the final twist was a bit unexpected - patricide when it was not confirmed exactly what the relationship was until very near the end. Still ultimately uninteresting.




Saturday 8th July 2023

2013

Bear Witness

unlisted author

Summary :
Releasing bears into the wild and the sex-life of a young female scientist

Reviewed by rogerco, on 08 Jul 2023

Review Summary :
Eco-warrior story very good, but the sex-life story very naff.

One part excellent, one part naff

We really could have done without allthe 20-something angst of sex. It was unconvincing at best and cringy at worst - it seemed todiminsh Callis as a strong character, or as a character discovering her strengths.

The eco story was strong, exploring the relationship between theoretical pure science (Callis's job), practical on the ground Goethian science (her encounters with live bears and living forests), science as a tool of politics (the Norwegian commission and the Euro and Scottish initiatives) and its interaction with people (changing public responses), and ecologerism - practical ecological philosophy intersecting with activism.

The back story of her college friends and a secret feminist society, together with her various couplings I found totally unconvincing, and made it much harder to like the lead character. Pretty soppy girly stuff.

Whilst reading it I was struck by the similarity with The Wold Border by Sarah Hall which Iread 7  years ago. It seeedlike  Mandy Haggith had taken the storyand added a romatic layer toit obscuring the core story - but on checking it seemsthe potential plagarism must have been theother way round with Sarah Hall stripping away the crud fromMandy's story and producing a much better book.

 Since they were written and published in fairlyquick succession (2013-2015) it is more likely tobe a case of synchronicity. 

 




Saturday 1st July 2023

Summary :
Dystopian post-deluvian future based on genetic engneering

Reviewed by rogerco, on 01 Jul 2023

Review Summary :
Somewhat disturbing, although perhaps not as likely as when it was written

Somewhat Disturbing

What could possibly go wrong (with genetic engineering). Interestingly the virus/pandemic that actually wiped out the human population (aside from Jimmy/Snowman perhaps) was a deliberate act by Crake taking it upon himself to play god (from the best possible rational motives). How does this relate to our recent/current experiences with mass vaccination and a rising excess death rate - we will find out.

The story is quite compelling, starting in the (storyline) present and exploring what went wrong through Snowman's dreams and memories of life before the event horizon. In litearal terms it is a somewhat unllikely tale (and since it was written in 2003 things aren'tturning out quite like that) but in liiterary terms as a metaphor  for what is actually happening it is a bit disturbing. 

The figure of the lone survivor trying to make sense of it all is as clear as the example of Pete Postlethwaite in Age of Stupid - in both cases because we can imagine that waypoint doesn't mean that it is inevitable, but in both cases it is compelling because it is a believable extrapolation from what we see aroud us.

Overal it was better than The Handmaiden's Tale as a read - maybe because it was easier to identify with the lead character. The ambiguity at the end (did he pul the trigger) is enough to make me likely to read the next in the trilogy. 




Sunday 18th June 2023

The Mortal Sickness

Lydmouth #2

Author : Andrew Taylor

Summary :
Everyday village murder mystery

Reviewed by rogerco, on 18 Jun 2023

Review Summary :
Simple and quite well told but the milieu is unconvincing

A bit Midsommer Murders-ery

Filled with tropes of 1950s English village life (is Lydmouth a large village or a small town - and given its name where is the sea?) and a fairly unconvncing plot. Some of the characters are entertaining (the reporter and the detective) but others are somewhat overdrawn (the mad woman and the laird) or just weak (the vicar and his wife).




Thursday 1st June 2023

Summary :
Young woman escapes from life in Oklahoma and is given an indian baby on the way - they end up in Arizona

Reviewed by Roger CO, on 01 Jun 2023

Review Summary :
Social realism of the Southern States

Nice slice of flyover life

Shit happens and you just get on with it. A story of resilience in the face of everyday life